The Supreme Court Steps In on Equestrian Selection: Fix the Machinery, Not Just the Match
The equestrian selection saga I wrote about last week reached the Supreme Court, and the top Court has done something more interesting than simply dismissing the appeal.
While the Supreme Court declined to provide relief on the individual dispute, and that is the end of the road for the athletes as far as the upcoming Asian Games are concerned, the Bench issued notice, expressly to address the institutionalisation process and to streamline the EFI's selection process.
The matter is now listed for August 24th, 2026.
The Bench's reasoning: "This Court would be very reluctant to keep interfering in sports. We can only do it in the context of institutionalisation... Individual persons coming at the last stage is getting worse."
This is the underlying problem and exactly what I have mentioned in the past. Courts do not want to be in the business of picking teams, and they should not be. But they keep being dragged in, one aggrieved athlete at a time, because the system upstream is not institutionalised: stopgap committees, criteria that shift late in the day, the lack of a settled, transparent process that athletes can rely on. The Court has now said, in effect, that the answer is not to keep hearing individual grievances at the eleventh hour. It is to fix the machinery that produces them.
Encouragingly, the architecture has existed for a while. A Ministry of Youth Affairs & Sports, Government of India circular of March 2025 requires NSFs to publish a standard selection policy, amend it no later than 3 months before an event, publicise mega-event criteria two years in advance, videograph trials, run a grievance mechanism, etc. Read against the EFI issue, that list is almost a diagnosis.
By letter dated July 9th, 2026, the MoYAS reminded every recognised NSF of exactly this, asking them to publish their Los Angeles 2028 qualification and selection pathway by July 15th, 2026.
That date has now passed. Which federations actually did it, and whether they hold to what they have published when the entries fall due, is what one must watch out for.
