Should Doping Be a Crime? Our 2017 Opinion to the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports
Update: The National Anti-Doping Act, 2022 is now in force, and draft provisions on doping-related offences were released for public consultation in 2026.
Following a consultation meeting on 27 April 2017 on drafting anti-doping legislation, the Ministry of Youth Affairs and Sports sought an opinion on whether India should make doping a criminal offence. AM Sports Law & Management Co. examined the stakeholders involved, the state of anti-doping awareness, international models and the Ministry’s discussions.
Shared responsibility
An effective regime depends on many people: the Ministries of Sports, Health and AYUSH, NADA and the National Dope Testing Laboratory, athletes, coaches and support staff, doctors, federations, administrators, physical education teachers, lawyers, doping control officers, chemists and journalists. Young athletes are the most vulnerable, often unaware of the rules and exposed to pressure to take prohibited substances.
Where awareness fell short
Awareness among athletes, coaches and support staff was low, and many athletes come from rural backgrounds where dense rules are hard to follow. Education sessions were neither mandatory nor engaging, the Code and the Prohibited List were not available in Indian languages, and the same material was delivered to every audience. A significant share of violations were inadvertent, such as an athlete buying medicine from a local chemist without realising it contained a prohibited substance, and many doctors were unfamiliar with the Prohibited List or with when to advise a Therapeutic Use Exemption. Athletes also face financial, family and performance pressures that call for access to counsellors and psychologists.
International models
In 2015 WADA opposed criminalising doping by athletes but encouraged governments to penalise those who traffic in and supply prohibited substances. Austria treats doping as sports fraud, punishable by up to three years’ imprisonment, rising to ten where the damage exceeds €50,000. Italy has a specific anti-doping law covering athletes and support personnel, and Germany’s 2016 law punishes self-doping by elite athletes with up to three years and suppliers with up to ten, though it has drawn criticism on proportionality. Italy, the Netherlands, Germany and France also criminalise trafficking.
Intention and inadvertence
The WADA Code 2015 did not define intention with clarity, and determining it relied on CAS jurisprudence. Where doping is intentional, we recommended understanding the reasons behind it and attempting reform before conviction. Where it is inadvertent, the answer is education on the sources of prohibited substances, including medicines, ayurvedic products and pain-relief gels, on TUEs, whereabouts, chain of custody and sabotage. Support personnel need training too. In the case of footballer Subrata Paul, the prescribing doctor did not specify which form of a cough syrup to take, and one form contained terbutaline, which shows how responsibility can lie with support personnel and how difficult criminal liability would be to apply fairly.
Our conclusion
We concluded that drafting a bill and inviting comment was a step in the right direction, but that criminalising doping at that time, with awareness as low as it was, risked imprisoning athletes who did not know the rules. We recommended that education come first, through measures including:
- anti-doping obligations in the sanction agreements between leagues and federations, extending to franchise owners;
- the Code and Prohibited List in ten to twelve Indian languages, in simplified form;
- compulsory, engaging and multimodal education, with practical demonstrations of how testing works;
- awareness among general practitioners, chemists and AYUSH manufacturers, including forms at chemists recording why an athlete is buying a medicine;
- a 24-hour helpline and an online portal where athletes can check whether a medicine is prohibited;
- rehabilitation support, including counselling, for athletes returning after long breaks;
- guidance on supplements and an additional laboratory for commercial supplement testing; and
- star athletes as ambassadors, with monthly state-level seminars.
Original Commentary
The complete paper covers this topic in greater depth.
Related Services
