AM Sports Law & Management
Gaming

The Online Gaming GST Judgment: What It Actually Means

Aahna MehrotraAahna Mehrotra
28 May 20263 min read

My two bits on yesterday's Supreme Court judgment on the online gaming GST issue:

First - the retrospective GST. The practical reality: The PROGAct was promulgated in Aug, 25 and came into force in May, 26. Most online RMG operators had already wound down, pivoted, or simply run out of road well before that. A tax claim is now being asserted against businesses that no longer exist, many of which used whatever capital they had left to start over elsewhere. The closest parallel to this that I can think of is the AGR saga in telecom. When the SC upheld the govt's AGR calculations in 2019, it created staggering liabilities for the likes of Vodafone and Airtel. Enforcement softened - payment timelines were restructured & the govt eventually ended up as a 49% shareholder in Vodafone. Why? Because (i) the industry had over two hundred million subscribers; (ii) it is critical national infrastructure; (iii) it was a duopoly the govt couldn't afford. It was in the govt's own interest to blink. None of that exists here. There are no stranded consumers, no infra at risk, no equity stake creating aligned incentives. The AGR playbook won't be available to online gaming companies because the conditions that made it viable simply don't apply. What they are left with is the adjudication process, contesting quantum, arguing on interest and penalties, and hoping that a govt which has already achieved its policy objective (of shutting shop) chooses not to pursue every rupee from companies that have already moved on (a hope, not a strategy).

The second observation - the more interesting of the 2 as a lawyer. The same bench that upheld the retrospective GST also upheld the Karnataka and Tamil Nadu state legislations banning online gaming for stakes. The court held that there is no fundamental right to engage in betting & gambling, and that states are fully within their constitutional authority under Entry 34 to ban these activities. The uncomfortable question that follows from this: if betting & gambling are a state subject, and the SC has now confirmed that states can regulate and ban these activities, what is the legislative basis on which the Centre imposed a nationwide ban through the PROG Act? Whether the Centre's reliance on Entry 52 or the online characterisation of these activities actually survives constitutional scrutiny remains to be determined. By so emphatically affirming state power over betting and gambling, the SC may have inadvertently handed ammunition to those challenging the constitutional validity of the PROG Act itself.

Not sure if the ban will be struck down anytime soon, but the legal chapter on this is far from closed. While it is interesting times ahead for us as lawyers, for an industry that has been through what this one has, it is a bitter irony worth sitting with.

P.S. – Preliminary thoughts as I am yet to read the judgment.

Get in touch

Ready to discuss your matter?

Our team advises governing bodies, athletes, leagues, broadcasters and brands on all aspects of sports law and management.

Book a Consultation →