AM Sports Law & Management
Business of Sport

Reviving Formula One in India: Why the Tax Boards Sit on the Task Force

Aahna MehrotraAahna Mehrotra
18 September 20262 min read

The government has set up a task force under NITI Aayog to examine reviving Formula One in India, thirteen years after the last Grand Prix at the Buddh International Circuit. It is chaired by a NITI Aayog Programme Director and includes Sports, Commerce and Tourism, the CBIC and the CBDT, the governments of Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra, the Buddh and Madras circuits, and the FMSCI.

The presence of the two tax boards is the part that matters, because tax is what pushed the Indian Grand Prix off the calendar in the first place.

The 2 distinct problems were as follows:

(i) Classification: F1 was treated as entertainment rather than sport, so it drew none of the concessions extended to sport and attracted entertainment levies instead. Back in 2009, the licensing fee payable to Formula One's commercial rights holder was caught in a remittance dispute on exactly this reasoning, that a motor race was entertainment and not a sport contributing to the country's sporting development.

(ii) Structural issues: In 2017, the Supreme Court held that the Buddh circuit was a permanent establishment of Formula One's commercial rights holder in India for the duration of the event. Its income was therefore taxable in India, and the Indian promoter was liable to withhold tax on what it paid out. That ruling is the current law on the point, and while no judgment is ever entirely beyond reconsideration, it is not something an executive task force can set aside. A workable revival, currently, must be designed around it, through the concession structure, the hosting arrangement, or a tax regime built for events of this kind.

Therefore, whether a Grand Prix works in India is a tax question well before it is a sporting one.

The intent seems right and the exercise has been long overdue. The value, however, will lie in whether it produces a real answer on the tax treatment.

Get in touch

Ready to discuss your matter?

Our team advises governing bodies, athletes, leagues, broadcasters and brands on all aspects of sports law and management.

Book a Consultation →