AM Sports Law & Management
Disputes

Equestrian Selection Again: A Fitness Dispute and the Case for a Documented Process

Aahna MehrotraAahna Mehrotra
11 September 20262 min read

Hriday Chheda, part of the dressage team that won India gold at the 2023 Asian Games, was nearly kept out of this year's Games when his horse, Dono Di Maggio, was declared clinically unfit. That finding would have ended his selection. He disputed it, an independent veterinary examination was ordered following an IOA intervention, the horse was cleared, and he remains in the team.

This is the same equestrian selection story I wrote about in July, surfacing again in a different form. Then, it was EFI finalising its team without complying with its own Selection Criteria, and a Division Bench finding the federation had acted with “undue haste” while the athletes still lost on the clock. Now it is a place on the Asian Games team hinging on a veterinary fitness report, and a dispute serious enough that it took an intervention from outside the selection process to resolve.

A horse's fitness to compete is a legitimate check, and welfare has to come first. No one should ride an unfit animal. But the process that makes that call has to be trusted by everyone bound by it, which means a documented procedure with a second opinion built in, not arranged after a dispute has already started. When an athlete has to escalate to be sure a fitness finding was sound, the process has not done its job, whatever the finding's merits.

The Supreme Court made the same point in the equestrian matter itself, when it said it was reluctant to keep interfering except on institutionalisation, and that athletes arriving at the last stage in distress was getting worse. A better rescue each time is not the fix. A settled process that makes the rescue unnecessary is.

For now the athlete competes, which is the right outcome. But a fitness call that needed an outside intervention to settle is not a process working as it should.

Get in touch

Ready to discuss your matter?

Our team advises governing bodies, athletes, leagues, broadcasters and brands on all aspects of sports law and management.

Book a Consultation →