AM Sports Law & Management
Disputes

EFI Found in Breach of Its Own Rules, and Still Won. The Calendar Is the Problem.

Aahna MehrotraAahna Mehrotra
7 July 20263 min read

Yesterday I wrote about two AsianGames selection cases, and mentioned that Anush Agarwalla had, “so far”, not succeeded. I had written it based on what I heard of the preliminary hearings, in the matter i.e., the challenge did not hold ground because the process followed had been found sound. It had not!

The Division Bench dismissed the appeals, so Agarwalla and Sudipti Hajela remain on the reserve list, however the Court did not hold that the EFI had followed its own rules. The Court found that EFI had not complied with Clauses 15(a) and 15(b) of its own Selection Criteria, which required the ‘Probables’ to compete once more before the team was finalised, and had failed to publish the mandatory provisional merit list of the ‘Probables’ under Clause 8(f). It went further, noting that EFI had acted with “undue haste” in uploading the final entries, and that its reasons for non-compliance “do not inspire confidence”. On the allegations of bias and conflict of interest, the Court expressly declined to decide, since the individuals concerned had not been made parties.

Despite the foregoing, the athletes lost - not on the merits, but on the clock. EFI finalised the ‘Probables’ only after the qualifying window had closed, and there was no longer time to hold the competition its own rules require. With horses and riders scattered across countries and the entry deadline looming, the Court held it was logistically impracticable to order a fresh trial, and declined to interfere “in the larger interest of the sport”. It directed EFI to strictly comply with the Selection Criteria going forward.

While a federation was found to have breached its own rules, it still prevailed, because by the time the matter was decided there was no time left to put things right. One can understand the Court’s pragmatism. Ordering a fresh trial days before an entry deadline, with horses in transit, could have jeopardised India’s participation altogether. But the uncomfortable truth underneath is that the federation’s own delay is what made the breach irreversible, and it was the athletes, not the federation, who paid for it.

In VineshPhogat’s case, the same Court looked hard at whether a federation had fairly applied its criteria, and pushed back where it had not. This recent trend is a shift of sorts where Courts are increasingly prepared to scrutinise the process. What the EFI judgment shows is the limit of that scrutiny: a court can find fault and still be unable to grant a remedy, if the calendar has run out.

Time has never been more of the essence!

Get in touch

Ready to discuss your matter?

Our team advises governing bodies, athletes, leagues, broadcasters and brands on all aspects of sports law and management.

Book a Consultation →