AM Sports Law & Management
Disputes

Two Asian Games Selection Cases, Two Outcomes: What Makes a Selection Decision Stand

Aahna MehrotraAahna Mehrotra
6 July 20262 min read

Team selection is where the governance of Indian sport most often ends up in court. Two recent Asian Games cases before the Delhi High Court, different results, show what makes a selection decision stand, and what makes it fall.

Kashish Malik, a taekwondo athlete, had been declared ineligible on the reasoning that her bronze in the Women’s Under-53 kg category no longer counted, because the said category had been merged into Under-57 kg. The Court found that reasoning to be, in effect, meritless: if the two categories have been merged, a medallist in the old one cannot simply be written out of the new. It asked the Centre to consider forwarding her name.

Anush Agarwalla fared differently. A single judge dismissed his petition on June 29, 2026 holding that the Equestrian Federation of India had applied its criteria fairly, with no arbitrariness or perversity to warrant interference. His appeal is now pending before a Division Bench, which has reserved judgment.

Same court, different outcomes (so far) - what explains both is a principle the courts have been uniform about for a long time: a court does not sit in appeal over selection on merits. It will not tell a federation who its best athlete is. It steps in only where the process is arbitrary, irrational, or where the body taking the decision is acting without authority. Malik succeeded because the reasoning against her failed that test. Agarwalla, so far, has not, because the federation was found to have followed its own criteria.

Having been in and around these disputes for the better part of a decade, my sense is that the more telling story is rarely the athlete’s grievance. It is the governance sitting behind it. In the equestrian matter, the selection was made by an ad hoc committee, and the Division Bench has itself questioned the basis on which that committee is still functioning, its 3 month tenure having lapsed. This is not new. In 2022, I acted for Diya Chitale in a selection matter we won, at a time when the federation was functioning under a committee of administrators.

Different sport, different year, the same underlying pattern: when a federation’s own house is unsettled, selection is where it shows.

Get in touch

Ready to discuss your matter?

Our team advises governing bodies, athletes, leagues, broadcasters and brands on all aspects of sports law and management.

Book a Consultation →